Traditional Ice Cream Flavors
All flavors available at the Bexley location with the exception of seasonal flavors. Flavors with an *asterisk are available at all Johnson's Real Ice Cream locations.
Please note our No Sugar Added (NSA) Ice Creams are currently available at our Bexley location only.
Banana
Banana Fudge
*Birthday Cake
*Black Raspberry Beret
Black Raspberry Chip
Black Walnut
*Blueberry Pie
*Blue Sky
*Bubblegum
*Buckeye Fever
*Get Butter, Pecan
*Butterscotch Toffee
*Campfire S'mores
*Cherry Cordial
*Chocolate Chocolate Chip
*Chocolate Fudge Brownie
*Cinnamon
*Coconut Almond Chip
*Coffee and the Cool Beans
*Columbus Crunch
*Cotton Candy
*Double Dutch Chocolate
*Lemon Cha Cha
*Mighty Mint and Chip
Mint Chocolate Chip, No Sugar Added
Mocha Chip
*Moose Tracks
*One Smart Cookie(s) and Cream
*Peach (Seasonal)
*Praline, You're Nuts
*Raspberry Cheesecake
*Rollin in the Cookie Dough
*Salty Caramel Chocolate Pretzel Trap
*Strawberry Jamboree
*Original Vanilla
*Triple Trouble Vanilla Bean
*Vanilla Chip
New Additions at Bexley
These flavors are so new, we haven't had time for a photo!
Black Cherry
Rocky Road
Unicorn Power
Moose Tracks (No Sugar Added)