New Albany Menu

We are excited to have a location in New Albany. Be sure to ask about our Eagles Nest Sundae exclusively available at our New Albany shop! (Pricing and offerings subject to change.)

Logo Johnson's Real Ice Cream


Includes sugar cone, cake cone or dish.

Single $3.50
Double $5.00
Triple $6.50

Waffle Cones, $1 extra
Chocolate-dipped Waffle Cone, $1.50 extra


Includes Whipped Cream, Nuts or Sprinkles and a Cherry!

Single $4.95
Double $5.95
Triple $6.95

Toppings: Just Ask! We have just about anything yummy!


Choose from any flavor!

Small Shake $4.95
Large Shake $5.25
Thick Shake add $.50
Malt add $.50

Root Beer Float: Root Beer with 1 scoop of Ice Cream.  $4.50


Banana Split: 3 scoops of Ice Cream, fresh Banana, Chocolate syrup, Strawberry topping, Pineapple topping, Nuts, Whipped Cream, and a Cherry.  $6.95

Buckeye Sundae: 1 scoop of Buckeye Fever Ice Cream topped with Hot Fudge, Spanish Peanuts, Whipped Cream, and Mini-Buckeyes. $4.95

Irish Sundae: 1 scoop of Mighty Mint and Chip Ice Cream topped with Hot Fudge, Oreo pieces, Whipped Cream, and a Cherry. $4.95

Turtle Sundae: 1 scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream, topped with Hot Fudge, Caramel, Pecans, Whipped Cream and a Cherry.  $4.95


Strawberry/Banana: Apple juice, Strawberries, Banana and Vanilla yogurt. $5.45

Tropical: Orange juice, Strawberries, Pineapple, Banana and Mango Sorbet. $5.45

Berry: Apple juice, Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries, and Pomegranate Blueberry Sorbet. $5.45


Nutty Buddy and Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwichs: $3.95 each

Buckeye Party: 3-pack  $3.99; 9-pack  $8.99

Real Ice Cream, Yogurt, Sorbet, and Sherbet: $5.45 pint

Ice Cream Cake: 9" round or 1/4 sheet. Starting at $37.95

Ice Cream Pies: Turtle, Vanilla, Oreo, and Mud. $19.95, Specialty Flavors $21.95

Fudge Logs: Vanilla, Oreo, Butter Pecan, Coffee, and Mint. $18.95, Specialty Flavors $18.95

Important Message from Johnson's

We would like to take a moment to address a divisive social media post from last evening regarding a wholesale customer of ours, Sunbury Fish and Chicken. At Johnson’s Real Ice Cream, we believe in the values of diversity and inclusion and are against any form of discrimination. For that reason, we have pulled our product from this shop and they will no longer be a customer of Johnson’s. In addition, we have asked them to take down the unauthorized signage depicting the Johnson's logo.

Johnson’s Real Ice Cream is a family-owned business and the community has supported us for 70 years. We are grateful for all of our customers and we will not stand for discrimination in any shape or form.


Matt and Jeff Wilcoxon