Our Flavors
Real handcrafted classics and new favorites made just for you. The ice cream menu may vary by location, so be sure to select your store and category using the filters below on the right hand side of the page.
Product filters
Products

Banana (Bexley only)
Real banana puree combined with sweet cream. Available at Bexley location only.
Traditional Flavor

Banana Fudge
Sweet banana ice cream swirled with chocolate fudge.
Traditional Flavor

Birthday Cake
Cake batter ice cream with a blue icing swirl and pieces of confetti cake.
Traditional Flavor

Biscoff® Cookie Butter
Back by popular demand, this rich and creamy cookie butter ice cream is filled with Biscoff® cookie pieces.
Traditional Flavor

Black Cherry (Bexley only)
Creamy cherry ice cream with chunks of black cherry.
Traditional Flavor

Black Raspberry Chip
Premium grown black raspberry ice cream with chunks of delectable chocolate give you a consistent flavor with each bite.
Traditional Flavor

Black Walnut (Bexley only)
Walnut ice cream with crunchy roasted Black Walnut pieces. Available at Bexley location only.
Traditional Flavor

Blue Sky
Dreamy blue vanilla ice cream with a marshmallow swirl perfect for cloud watching on a lazy summer day.
Traditional Flavor

Blueberry Pie
Refreshing vanilla ice cream with a blueberry ripple and graham cracker pieces.
Traditional Flavor

Buckeye Fever
Locally sourced Krema peanut butter ice cream loaded with rich chocolate chips makes this a real fan favorite.
Traditional Flavor

Butter Pecan
With a flavor reminiscent of melted toffee, this butter pecan ice cream has fresh, roasted, salted pecans.
Traditional Flavor

Butter Pecan - No Sugar Added (Bexley only)
Sweetened with Splenda, this Butter Pecan allows everyone to enjoy this flavor. Available at Bexley.
No Sugar Added

Butterscotch Toffee
Butterscotch ice cream loaded with chocolate covered toffee pieces.
Traditional Flavor

Campfire S'mores
The campfire treat meets the freezer with this graham cracker ice cream with a marshmallow swirl and chunks of graham cracker.
Traditional Flavor

Cappuccino Yogurt (Bexley only)
Coffee yogurt with a hint of cinnamon and chocolate espresso chips. Available Bexley location only.
Yogurt

Cherry Cordial
Amaretto ice cream loaded with maraschino cherries and delicious chocolate chips
Traditional Flavor

Chocolate Chocolate Chip
Chocolate lovers crave this chocolate ice cream packed with chocolate chips.
Traditional Flavor

Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Rich cocoa and sweet cream with chewy brownie bits and a fudge swirl make this a chocolate lover’s favorite.
Traditional Flavor

Chocolate Peanut Butter
Rich chocolate ice cream with Krema peanut butter layered throughout.
Traditional Flavor

Cinnamon
Sweet ground cinnamon ice cream that’s the perfect complement to your apple pie.
Traditional Flavor

Coconut Almond Chip
Coconut ice cream with fresh roasted almonds and rich chocolate chips.
Traditional Flavor

Coffee
Exceptional coffee flavor with 100% Arabica beans in a sweet frozen treat.
Traditional Flavor

Columbus Crunch
A hometown favorite, this creamy vanilla ice cream has a crunchy blend of Oreo's®, chocolate toffee pieces, chocolate chips and rainbow sprinkles.
Traditional Flavor

Cookie Dough
Rich cookie dough ice cream with cookie dough chunks and chocolate chips.
Traditional Flavor

Cookies and Cream
Sweet cream loaded with Oreo® and chocolate cookie pieces.
Traditional Flavor

Cotton Candy
The happiness of the carnival is found in this cotton candy ice cream with multi-colored candy-covered chocolate pieces.
Traditional Flavor

Dairy Free Double Chocolate
Rich Chocolate ice cream made with a coconut cream base.
Dairy Free

Dairy Free Mint Chocolate Chip
Refreshing Mint ice cream with rich chocolate chips made with a coconut cream base.
Dairy Free

Dutch Chocolate
A classic flavor still made the way Great Grandpa Johnson used to do it, with the finest cocoa powder imported from Holland.
Traditional Flavor

Lemon
Refreshing lemon in locally sourced sweet cream.
Traditional Flavor

Lemon Sorbet
A bright dairy free lemon puree.
Sorbet

Mango Sorbet
The tropical flavor of mango will take you to the islands in this refreshing dairy free frozen Mango puree.
Sorbet

Mint Chocolate Chip
A cool blend of rich chocolate chips and mint ice cream.
Traditional Flavor

Mint Chocolate Chip - No Sugar Added (Bexley and Canal Winchester)
Green mint ice cream with small chocolate chips without the added sugar. Available at Bexley and Canal Winchester locations only.)
No Sugar Added

Mocha Chip (Bexley only)
A blend of refreshing coffee ice cream with chocolate chips. Available at Bexley location only.
Traditional Flavor

Moose Tracks
A chunky fudge swirl and miniature peanut butter cups in smooth vanilla ice cream.
Traditional Flavor

Moose Tracks - No Sugar Added (Bexley only)
Available at Bexley location only.
No Sugar Added

Orange Sherbet
Orange juice and cream make the perfect combination.
Sherbet

Original Vanilla
The purest flavor of vanilla, uncomplicated, untouched.
Traditional Flavor

Peppermint Stick
Peppermint Stick
Traditional Flavor

Pink Peppermint
Pink Peppermint
Traditional Flavor

Praline Pecan
Sweet vanilla ice cream with a caramel swirl and caramelized pecans.
Traditional Flavor

Rainbow Sherbet
A delicious blend of lime, orange and lemon.
Sherbet

Raspberry Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake ice cream swirled with raspberry puree and graham cracker bites.
Traditional Flavor

Raspberry Sorbet
Premium grown seedless black raspberries pureed for a refreshing and flavorful non-dairy treat.
Sorbet

Salty Caramel Chocolate Pretzel
A delicious blend of chocolate covered pretzel pieces and vanilla ice cream with ribbons of salted caramel.
Traditional Flavor

Strawberry
Strawberry ice cream swirled with ripe whole strawberries.
Traditional Flavor

Triple Vanilla Bean
A triple dose of pure Madagascar vanilla ice cream with flecks of vanilla bean.
Traditional Flavor

Vanilla Chip
Silky vanilla ice cream mixed with rich chocolate chips.
Traditional Flavor